Read Leif Montgomery's Guide to Choosing a Massage Oil, Creme, Lotion or Gel

One of the most common questions I get asked is: “How do I choose a massage lubricant”?

Massage Lubricants are used to reduce friction, allowing optimal interaction between the practitioner and receiver.

The main characteristics of Massage Lubricants are glide and viscosity:

Glide:  Glide refers to the amount of friction or control.

On one side the spectrum you have acupressure, or trigger point work, where no glide is desirable. Here, there will be no or very little lubricant used.

On the other end, you have very superficial or circulatory massage, where there will be a lot of slip, and only the top layers of tissue affected.

In between those two extremes, we have the varying degrees of friction allowing deeper work into the tissue.  While massage lubricants are designed to stay on the skin surface, each will have varying degrees of uptake (The Absorption Rate) into the skin.  This will affect the amount of glide.

Viscosity: Viscosity refers to the thickness of the lubricant.  Oil has the lowest viscosity, very liquid, and cream the highest. Within the categories of massage lubricants, there are also varying degrees of viscosity.  For instance, there are thinner oils (fractionated coconut), or heavier blends of oils (Almond), as well as thicker or less dense creams.

What is the correct Glide/Viscosity Factor (GVF) for you?

Determining your optimal Glide/Viscosity Factor (GVF) will depend on several factors:

  1. Personal Preference
  2. Modality or Technique Performed
  3. Desired Outcome

1. Personal Preference
There is no right or wrong here.  With experience, each practitioner will find their sweet spot or correct GVF .  You will probably hear the statement that oil is used for Swedish massage and cream for deep tissue.  That is an over generalization or simplification.  The fact is, many experienced practitioners use oil and a variety of lubricants for advanced or deeper massage and conversely, creams can be used for Swedish massage.  You will come to find which lubricant type you prefer and learn to use it correctly to achieve the desired outcome.

2. Modality or Technique Performed
The modality or technique performed will determine the amount of grip/friction and glide needed.  Swedish massage, and modalities focusing on circulation, require a fair amount of glide.  Trigger point, Myo Fascial, and Deep Tissue require less glide and more grip.

Is your massage treatment general and gliding, specific and deep, fast or slow?…… all of these questions will determine your GVF.

3. Desired Outcome
Another factor to consider for your GVF is desired outcome.  Generally speaking, the massage lubricant is secondary to the reason people get a massage from you – your hands or manual skills.  The lubricant just facilitates this and is not the focus.  However, there may be other considerations to ponder: the “oiliness” factor left on a client after the session, care of linens, moisturizing or skin care effects, and therapeutic properties of the lubricant.

Categories of  Massage Lubricants

Oils
On the viscosity scale, oil is the least viscous, most liquid.  Because of this, it has a high glide coefficient and is suitable for treatments or modalities requiring less friction.  However, as stated above, there is some wiggle room here.  Use very little oil, and friction increases.   Because oil is liquid, it can be messy and easily spilled…. something to consider.  Pump Bottles and Holsters can help keep your treatment space clean.

Further considerations:  Because oils contain no water, they require little or no preservative.  Vitamin E is sometimes added to act as a preservative, but its effectiveness in this capacity is up for debate.  However, use caution.  Oils can turn rancid very quickly.  My nose can sense this very quickly.  I have known practitioners to use oil well beyond its freshness date.  The easiest way to determine freshness is to do the smell test.  If it smells like vanish or polish, it’s bad.  Most oils have little or no scent.  Some, like olive and jojoba, have distinctive scents and you can readily distinguish between its inherent scent, and rancidity.  Scented oils will make freshness harder to determine.

Types:  Most manufacturers produce blends of oils for massage.  Read the ingredient list on the bottle to determine what’s in your oil, or see our ingredient guides on the below links.

Let’s look at some specific oil properties:

Almond (and other nut oils) – Almond oil is a common ingredient in many oils.  However, nut oils as of late, have become ingredient non grata.  I think some if this is unfounded and nut oil allergies are overstated. It could very well be rancidity causing the issues.

Grapeseed Oil -  I love the oil.  It is super moisturizing and beneficial for the skin and has medium viscosity within the oil family.  Please note, grapeseed oil can be very staining to clothes and linens!

My favorites – Coconut and Jojoba. This is my preferred blend for the following reasons:  they are very stable, meaning have a long shelf life (well over 1 year without any preservatives).  They are also very clean was wash easily out of linens, a big bonus.

Coconut Oil is solid at room temperature.  Fractionated Coconut Oil is the liquid form of coconut oil. This is, in fact, a much more desirable form of coconut oil, because it is much more stable than regular coconut oil and retains a higher percentage of its anti oxidant properties.  Technically, this is achieved by removing almost all the long chain triglycerides present in the oil (which is the least stable portion prone to oxidation), via the safe process of hydrolysis and steam distillation.

Jojoba Oil is actually a wax ester, not strictly an oil.  However, it has the appearance and viscosity of an oil, so we refer to it commonly as such. Pure Natural Jojoba  (pronounced ho-ho’ba), is a botanical extract derived from jojoba seeds producing the pure liquid esters.  Because of its oxidative stability and complex structure of long chains of fatty acids, Jojoba is the ideal lubricant for massage and skin health.

Coconut and Jojoba, like my favorite beer and coffee, are also more expensive than standard oils.

My pick, which includes both Coconut and Jojoba, is Pure Lite Oil by Solace.

Gels
Gels are a very popular lubricant choice for many practitioners.  Gels are produced by starting with an oil and adding a wax base, producing a thicker oil with a higher viscosity.  Proponents of gel claim it has glide of an oil, with the workability of a lotion.  Treating dry skin or working  through hairy skin may benefit from the use of gels.

Popular gels include Biotone Advanced Therapy Massage Gel the original and one of the best is hypoallergenic and Bon Vital Original and Naturale Massage Gel with added botanicals.

Biotone Healthy Benefits – their latest, it’s new.  Send me your feedback on it!

Lotions
Lotions take us up the viscosity scale and also introduce the use of water into the equation.  This has the following ramifications:  Water and Oil do not mix – necessitating the need of  emulsifiers, stabilizers and similar substances.

Preservatives – when you add water, unless you plan on using it quick or freezing it, you must add a preservative, or else you will produce a science experiment like in high school.  Remember those? Lotion, while more viscous than oils and gels, are all easily pumpable, whether from the Gallon jug or 4 or 8 oz bottles.  There are many lotions on the market.  All will have similar viscosity, but the texture and feel will be slightly different across the board.  A lotion’s overall characteristics will be determined by how the manufacture creates the water/oil emulsion, via the stabilizing agents and ingredients used. I urge you to have fun and test and experiment with lotions.

Notable Lotions:

Biotone Nutri Naturals Lotion
Soothing Touch Jojoba Lotion
Sacred Earth Warming Lotion
Bon Vital Therapeutic Touch Lotion

Creams
Creams represent the thickest or highest viscosity of all the lubricants.  When considering a cream, keep in mind that the thickest choices are not pumpable.  Non pumpable creams can be applied from a jar or a tube. Many tubes are refillable for convenience.  The correct procedure here is to draw from a bulk jug (gallon or half gallon) via a clean spatula or spoon, into a jar or tube.  If a jar is used, it must be cleaned and refreshed for each client.  Please note, for creams that are pumpable, these pumps are heavier duty than those pumps for lotion.  Do not attempt to use  lotion or oils pumps for cream!

Nice cream to try:  Sacred Earth makes a 21oz size Vegan Massage Cream with a powerful pump.

Soothing Touch Massage Creams:  Please note: The Gallon sizes are pumbable.  The 62oz and 13oz sizes are not.  Perplexing, I agree.

Again, like lotions, there are countless types of cream for you to try and experiment with.  Each will have its own unique overall feel.

No discussion of massage creams would be complete without a discussion of Biotone Dual Purpose Cream, uh, Creme, that is, from Biotone.  This is without a doubt, the standard, the original, the cream (creme) that all others are judged by.  If imitation is the sincerest form of flattery, then Biotone is top dog of the creams.  The shear number of copycats is mind boggling, and the tortured names to try and ride Dual Purposes coat tails is bewildering:  Multi Purpose,  All Purpose, and so on.  I suggest On Purpose, or Tri Purpose!  Anyone else have some good names?

Something has troubled me for a long time. What does “dual purpose” stand for? I think the answer is in this next clip.  Watch LaVelle from Biotone:

Nice job LaVelle!  You get the Lief Montgomery thumbs up for clear product presentation and Biotone mission statement.  However, I did catch an error. Dual Purpose does not come in 1/2 Gallon size. It is actually a confounding 68oz – 1/2 Gallon + 4 oz.  Like the mysterious “Dual Purpose” definition, LaVelle, please clear up thought behind the size choice.  Is it a  Feng Shui thing, or maybe a metric thing?  You do prefer the French creme to the more common cream.  Merci.

Labels
You will find a lot of labels, like Natural and Organic, thrown around on products these days. Customers make a lot of assumptions about what these mean.  I have also found that it’s hard to get a straight answer from anyone on this subject.

The term Natural is so broad, general, vague, mis-used and abused, to make it practically irrelevant.  I recommend disregarding the “Natural” label and carefully reading the labels and ingredient list to make sure it fits your needs and expectations.

Here are some of the additives I found in a popular  “Natural” massage cream: (Cetearyl Alcohol, Polysorbate 60, Phenoxyethanol, Diazolidinyl Urea (and) Iodopropynyl Butylcarbamate, Carbomer)

How’s that for “natural”!

Organic
The Organic label is very similar.  Perhaps there will be several organic ingredients in the list, with the rest a mix of Latin and multi syllable chemical structures you might even hesitate before putting in your car’s radiator.  Just kidding! I am exaggerating, a little. Just read the label please!

Hypoallergenic
The hypoallergenic label usually refers to products free of any fragrance, scents, or nut oils.  This does not guarantee that it will not cause allergies or irritation to someone.  Always test first with sensitive types.  Oddly enough, we find the toughest reaction and allergy issues are resolved by using a completely unnatural solution…. Petroleum based lubricants  You would be surprised at how many common (and high end!) consumer moisturizers and lotions are either petroleum based or have some petroleum derivatives in the ingredient list.

Vegan
The Vegan label is perhaps the most interesting of them all.  Vegan?  Sacred Earth is the only brand I know of spouting this label.  Does this mean that Bon Vital and Biotone are not?  I am familiar with Vegan in terms of food – the lack of animal products.  I am pretty sure that none of the major brands we are discussing here include animal products.

On this same theme, many massage lubricant manufacturers advertise that they do not test their products on animals.  I find this hard to believe.  I get lots of samples of massage oils, lotions and cream in my travels.  I take them home and always test it on my dog first.  And she LOVES IT!!!! So listen up manufacturers, you have it backwards.  Label it, Certified Massage tested on animals and they LOVED IT! You can thank Leif for that.



Ingredients
So now we come to the topic of ingredients.  For some reason, people freak out about their massage lubricant over certain ingredients.  For instance, parabens has been all but excluded as an additive.  I understand the concern and agree that I want products as clean, fresh and high quality as possible. But please do not freak out on Lief until you checked the ingredient list from all the products, soaps, shampoos, moisturizers, make up, deodorants, in your own bathroom.  If they are all “pure”, then go ahead and freak out.  The fact is, across the board, the massage lubricants that I mention here from the major manufacturers are as high quality, or higher quality, that those products in general use by most people.  So rest assured please.  If you happen to be particularly discerning, demand strict purity, will not use any preservative, then you will have to do a little extra work, pay higher prices, and make some compromises.  We will compile a complete ingredient list for you to reference of the major massage lubricants as well as a glossary of some of the more esoteric ingredients you’ll come across. (Look for this in about 1 week)

Additives – Specialty
As I mentioned earlier, the focus of the massage treatment is the massage/manual skills of the practitioner.  The choice of the lubricant, with the correct GVF, merely facilitates this.  Additives refer to the addition of herbs, extracts, and essences to achieve a biologic effect, as well as add a little scent.  Examples include arnica, ivy, or ilex herbs, extracts of seaweed, algae, and essences of lavender, chamomile, ginger, etc.  There are many different additives used in lubricants.  Here is a partial list with functions.  (coming soon)

The specialty lubricants I am referring to are the ones creating heat or cold sensations when applied.  These will be used alone as a topical treatment, or in conjunction with massage/manual treatment.  The active ingredient that creates the heat/cool effect is Menthol or Camphor or a combination of the two.  The higher the concentration of Menthol, the stronger the effects. If you are doing spot treatments, higher concentration is OK.  If you are including massage to the area, or even full body massage, lower concentration is advised.  Please keep in mind, as I am sure you are aware, there is a smell associated with these products.

Examples:
Biofreeze – most common and popular.  Strong, used for spot work or re sold for clients to take home and apply.
Biotone Polar Lotion
Soothing Touch Herbal Heat or Herbal Ice
Bon Vital Sport Gel
Tiger Balm

I have heard it mentioned that practitioners sometimes dilute these formulas by adding to unscented lotions or creams and using as a whole body lubricant.  Not my cup of tea, but some might find it useful.

Cost Per Treatment
A useful and illuminating exercise is to determine your lubricant cost per treatment.  I mention this because I lean toward using high quality products and ingredients.

Many practitioners feel they are constrained by price.  So lets do the math.  The rule of thumb is 1oz of cream used per treatment.  For oils of lotions, it may be a little higher than 1oz.  So for a base price of $50 per Gallon of Cream, you would perform 128 treatments.  This works out to around 40 cents per treatment.  So lets say on the high end we use a $90 cream.  This equals 70 cents.  A $25 cream (I do not know any, nor do I want to!…..knowing some major ingredient/water substitution would need to be made) equals 20 cents.  Using that formula and tweaking for your preferences and use should give you some perspective on the money factor.  Is 40-60 cents unreasonable per treatment?  As an independent practitioner, using a cheaper lubricant and saving 15 cents per treatment saves about $5 a week based on 30 treatments.  If you are a clinic or spa owner, with multiple rooms, that changes the equation and you will have to decide what is appropriate.  Keep this in mind, you can always advertise that you use such and such expensive formula in your treatments, sending the message that you care and are focused on the details.  Conversely, you would not want it be to known, you use cheap brand X! I once heard that mineral oil (baby oil) was being used in those massage store fronts popping up all over New York and the East Coast.  Why not motor oil (recycled)!

If you do use a high end product, you may want to consider offering retail sizes for re sale, or give samples free if you prefer, for take home.  The take home product would be an altered version of the massage lubricant, because honestly speaking, massage lubricants are not the best choice for home skin care and moisturizing (they are designed for massage).  We can discuss this idea more in a later segment.

Measurements/Specs
I need to add this section because I find people often stumble over ounce/Gallon conversions.  So we do not embarrass ourselves, let’s study the following!

128oz = Gallon
64oz = ½ Gallon
32oz = Quart
16oz = Pint
8oz =  Cup
Now, if you say crème and I say cream, tomato/tomato, then we’ll go metric:

1 liter = 33.8140226 US fluid ounces
1 Gallon = 3.78 liters

Laundry Care and Precaution
The combination of linens, oil, and heat can create a combustible combination during drying and storage.  Use care, lower temperature settings in the dryer and read your dryers manufacturer guidelines for care of linens that have been exposed to oil.

Best practices for care and cleaning of your linens.  Clean your linens as soon as possible after use. The longer they sit with oil, the more difficult it will be to clean.  Try not to overuse your massage lubricant, otherwise all the excess will end up on the sheets.   As we stated above, certain oils are much cleaner and easier to launder out of sheets than others, lotions and even more so creams tend to collect less in linens.  If you find difficulty in getting your sheets clean, consider a specialty detergent designed to work just on getting out oil.  Eventually, you will have to replace your sheets. Just the cost of doing business.  If they are stained and have a rancid smell, do not delay in replacing. Customers pick up on queues and make judgments based on this.  You want to present your best image.

Leif Montgomery, vegan, natural and hypoallergenic, VNH

P.S. I’ve heard rumors from P.E.T.A. that vegans have more fun….